[General] Maxwell's

[Dr Grahame Blackwell]

Dear John W,

I'd be very interested to see your derivation, not of Maxwell's Equations, but of the nature of space, time and energy that you use as your platform for deriving Maxwell's Equations.

I'm not clear how it would be possible to derive a robust well-evidenced model of space-time-energy that:
(a) doesn't reference (directly or indirectly) Maxwell's Equations or any findings derived (directly or indirectly) from those equations or any of the previously-derived electrical and magnetic relationships from which Maxwell compiled his well-structured summation of those relationships;
(b) doesn't draw on any form of post-hoc rationalisation or circular argument;
but yet
(c) provides a basis for formulation of a set of electromagnetic field interrelationships.

One concern in particular (though not the only one) is how one defines a model of space-time-energy that (presumably) makes no use of prior findings on electricity or magnetism but yet is able to provide a basis for deriving relationships between electricity and magnetism.  Specifically, how does one _define_ the terms 'electricity' and 'magnetism' (or 'electromagnetic') without reference to any of that prior work?

Thanks,
Grahame
  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: John Williamson 
  To: Hodge John ; Nature of Light and Particles - General Discussion 
  Sent: Sunday, November 05, 2017 11:26 AM
  Subject: Re: [General] Maxwell's


  Dear all,

  Please remember I have derived the Maxwell equations, and more, from just the nature of space, time and energy.

  Relativity, in the sense that Andre has talked about as the transformations of energy and momentum, are then derived from this in both the modified theory I am working on now and in the two SPIE papers in 2015.

  Regards, John.


------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.natureoflightandparticles.org/pipermail/general-natureoflightandparticles.org/attachments/20171105/ac4e9f6b/attachment.html>